[sandyc316]

@explorer Maybe that’s one way to look at it.. but maybe not everyone will agree to it. For me, personally, I would like @drjaysee or rathi_b to post those messages and then make my decision based on that. Whether I choose to ignore that info all together or not, that’s up to me.
As for this forum turning into a ‘platform of manipulators’, I think your concerns are unfounded. Each post here is moderated by the admin (and maybe some moderators in future) and each user is validated. However, in spite of that, it won’t be possible to convince everyone that this is a genuine forum with genuine users. (As an example.. a few folks in the MC forum think that this is run by the company.) I think we should be ok to live with that.

[nitin_asce]

@drjaysee I think that you got a response because of your email id.

I am still waiting a response from IR but till date no response.

[Logan]

I request everyone not to post/share details of any meet with the management team or any replies from the company.

When we have this much uncertainty we thought sharing information would make us United but turns out it’s doing the opposite and it’s dividing us.

[Sobha]

Request the friends like Rathi, @drjaysee and others to share information whenever available. That is helpful. For that this type of forums also. But judging the correctness of information is an individual matter. You see MMB. so much information is there. But people know, what to take and what to not take. These information often helps very much

[buffet]

@sobha I agree..Very simple thing – if some1 don’t believe in particular post, simply ignore. If someone genuinely trying to help or share something important,please don’t discourage them. I am really not sure what’s problem. We all are matured enough. Let’s not call eachother this nd that. Otherwise this forum will turn out to be another MC board.

[Raj]

Logan, please ignore. Its not for you. Its for people who come here and write without proper evidence. Whatever you speak/write about the industry here makes sense.

[Raj]

Dear all, no offense to anyone. Its just the delay in communication in issues which is getting the matters worse. I am an investor in bcg since 4 years. I hope things gets sorted out within a day or two. Thanks & best wishes to all the friends. Cheers.

[buffet]

@drjaysee thanks for providing update. I appreciate you spent time & efforts to inform every1. I am also puzzled why can’t management simply inform the same through exchanges. Anyways let’s wait & watch for few more days.

[drjaysee]

Dear @ Logan and all, Totally I agree with you (but I thought that it would have been much helpful to judge the happenings at BCG internally). My sincere apologies & interruption and let me delete my message & deal BCG legally through proper channel of Min of Foreign & Min of Corporate Affairs for any kind of further follow-up considering the risk & volume of my investment. Let’s continue to be united and focus on the development /technical as usual. Thank you all.

[Remesh]

I request everyone including Rathi_b and Dr. Jayasree to post whatever info they get regarding this particular company. Please understand that most investors have found such info useful and they are grateful to you people. Explorer has the right to disbelieve you. But he doesn’t have any right to order not to post if you can’t prove what you post. Let each individual use their own common sense to believe or disbelieve what someone posts here. A guy named GKIyer always posts NCLT updates soon after the hearing and whatever info he has posted regarding that were true so far. But there also some people come and try to insult him so that he won’t post the info going forward. It is not to Dr. Jayasree that the doubtful person should ask ‘why only you?’. If he is bothered, he should ask it to the company officials.

[Logan]

@drjaysee, please don’t apologise to anyone. You haven’t done anything wrong. Thank you for sharing those details with us and Please don’t delete that post.

Some may like it and some may not but it’s because of you sharing the details that we all got more clarity.

[drjaysee]

Dear @Logan, Sorry, I have already deleted my message and I didn’t expect this kind of negative impact from my “shared message” and really don’t want to spoil/liquidate/deviate the genuine technical & in-depth discussions at this professional forum. I have great respect to one and all who have present in this forum and want to continue enjoy by reading all expert’s insights about BCG. Anticipating the bright show of BCG’s real potential in the coming days which may not too far from now…Thank you

[explorer]

For those who say “take the advise or leave it” – what’s the difference between mmb and this forum? When this forum was started, I found it useful because we were discussing about the company, its performance, results, issues etc. Now it has become management’s main channel of communication. Not very far before people start distrusting this forum.

[explorer]

^** take the info or leave it

[Sobha]

@explorer, please avoid blames against others. Anybody can charge against anybody else with such blames. But many times whoever are unnecessarily criticised are genuine investors and with some good information.

Somebody can criticize you also…. as if.. you want to prevent a genuine information as you have vested interest. You can be charged with agent of management or agent of operator. It is not difficult to find a partial logic for that.
Please keep away from such things.
The forum has helped retail investors like me very much. I am thankful to the admin as well as other friends who were providing genuine information and analysis.

Any form can be utilised by anybody depending on their capacity. Everybody has to be vigilant on that. But making bad comments upon others will not help.

[radhutheoptimist]

As long as promotors are not transparent of their activities they don’t deserve any respect. If someone says they received personal message to clarify certain issues we retail investors need to take it with pinch of salt. It may not be the fault of the person who posted the clarification but it could be some other game played by the management. I still trust the books of BCG as I feel it is not easy to fool the authoroties so blatantly for such a long time. But kind of fed up with the on going game in the market. Hope this ends soon.

[explorer]

@sobha my main concern is that the management has shared some information to some investors and I’m not sure how reliable that they are. For example, it has shared EY audit results to the investors who went to the office. I live abroad and I can’t afford to visit the company in person. Am I less privileged then? EY audit report will be a crucial info for an investor to make decision. Is it not like sharing an insider information to certain people? This kind of attitude from the management is what drives the investors away and we are happy encouraging that because we believe we are getting some benefits. If you are happy with the management sharing info to selected people, then don’t complain if the management doesn’t share the dividend info with you. Maybe they would have shared that with the selected individuals and you are not privileged enough to know that.

[explorer]

Sharing any information to the selected individuals about the company that’s not on the public domain and that will influence an investor to make buy/sell decision is nothing but sharing insider information. Some members in the forum had that insider information when the Hyderabad team met the management and you all hailed the team. Not all 40k investors know about this forum and the ones who are not in this forums don’t have the insider information. Similarly now we don’t know about the dividend status and I’m surprised you guys are complaining about it. Why double standards?

[Sobha]

@explorer, Please don’t aim at person. I am very much critical of promoters and today morning some friend criticised me for terming the management as corrupt.

Having said that there are some other things. In a concall skr told – “EY audited the Israel subsidiary. The papers are in the office and anybody can visit.” Two friends, in different times – Rati and Hitesh certified the claim through the forum after visiting the office.
Skr called everybody. Two friends visited. Whether they should share the information or not? Sharing will help many. But one can doubt also that. Nobody is saying to not doubt or not to be critical. But personally attacking them and questioning their intention so long as somebody is proved misdirecting is not a good thing. That will discourage those who take efforts. On the other hand we should be thankful to the services others are doing. That is all.

[explorer]

If you think we have collective responsibility we should be putting pressure on the management to disclose the needed information through the exchanges and not to the individuals. Can someone quote the messages in this forum even in the conference call? I’m sure the management will refuse that. If that’s the legality why do we confuse the innocent investors?

[Author]

Posts